High Risk Merchant Account Canada: What Merchants Should Know
Compliance Guide

Supplement Claims and Payment Processing: What the FTC Expects

By Julien Moreau | CERF | 7 min read

Supplement claims affect payment processing because an acquirer approves the marketing as well as the business. If a product page promises a result that the evidence cannot support, the application can be declined, or approved and later closed. The standard that underwriters borrow comes from the FTC: health claims need competent and reliable scientific evidence.

What the FTC standard says

In December 2022 the FTC replaced its 1998 dietary supplement advertising guide with the Health Products Compliance Guidance. It applies to supplements, foods, devices and any other product sold with health claims. The key points for a merchant are short.

  • Efficacy and safety claims need substantiation, and randomized controlled human trials are the usual form
  • No fixed number of studies is required, but one sound study counts for more than several flawed ones
  • Animal studies, lab studies, observational studies and anecdotes generally do not support a claim on their own
  • Botanicals and traditional remedies get no exemption, and traditional use can be described only if the wording does not imply proven benefits
  • Words such as "may," "helps" or "promising" do not fix a claim that lacks evidence

This is a summary, not legal advice. Have a lawyer who handles supplement marketing review your pages.

Structure and function claims

Supplements can describe how an ingredient supports the structure or function of the body, for example supporting normal energy levels. They cannot claim to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent a disease. Structure and function claims also need the standard FDA disclaimer on the label, which says the statement has not been evaluated by FDA and that the product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease.

Underwriters read both. A product that says it supports focus is usually fine. A product that says it treats anxiety or reverses a condition is a drug claim, and most acquirers will stop there.

Where claims hide

Brands usually check the home page and forget the other places. Underwriters check all of them.

  • Product page titles, image alt text and meta descriptions
  • Customer reviews and testimonials that describe results
  • Blog posts that discuss the product and a condition together
  • Affiliate and influencer pages, which the brand may not control
  • Email sequences and checkout upsell copy

If a customer review says the product cured something, hiding it is not enough. Do not feature it, and moderate what you publish.

What a clean claim looks like

A claim an acquirer accepts is specific, limited to the ingredient and written in plain language. It names the ingredient and the amount, says what the ingredient is known to support, and stops there. It does not promise a timeline, a number or an outcome for a particular person. If the evidence is for a different dose or population, the page should reflect that.

Photos matter too. Before and after images, medical imagery and white coats imply a drug claim even if the text is careful.

How this connects to your account

Claims decide whether your file reaches approval, and they also decide whether it stays approved. Acquirers recheck sites, and new pages with stronger wording can lead to a review. Our guide on why supplement accounts get closed covers the other triggers, and the document guide lists what to prepare alongside your claims.

A monthly review routine

Claims drift over time, so a one time review is not enough. Once a month, search your own site for words such as cure, treat, prevent, reverse and clinically proven, then read the results in context. Check your top five traffic sources for new pages, ask affiliates to send any new creative before it goes live, and keep dated screenshots of the pages that were approved. If an acquirer asks about a page, you can show what it looked like at approval and what you changed.

If you want an acquirer's view before you apply, send the page to us. We place supplement brands through our nutraceutical merchant account program and can tell you what to change first.

Not Sure How Your Claims Will Be Read

Send us your product page and ad copy. We will flag the wording an acquirer is likely to question before you apply.

Get Your Page Reviewed