Home › Blog › Supplement Free Trial Billing
Supplement Free Trials and Subscriptions: How Billing Terms Affect Your Merchant Account
By Julien Moreau | CERF | 4 min read
A free trial gets a customer in the door. Thirty days later the card is charged, the customer does not recognise the name on the statement, and a dispute is filed. For supplement brands this is the most common path to a high dispute ratio. This guide explains why trial offers create disputes, what the law expects, and which billing terms make a merchant account easier to keep.
Trial offers create disputes because customers forget what they agreed to
The customer signs up on day one and moves on. The first charge arrives weeks later, often after the product has run out or was never opened. The customer sees a payment they do not remember, and the fastest way to get the money back is to call the bank. The bank opens a dispute, and the dispute counts toward your ratio even if your terms were on the page. Most of these disputes are avoidable, because the cause is usually a forgotten sign up and involves no fraud.
The law expects clear disclosure, express consent and an easy way to cancel
In the US, the Restore Online Shoppers' Confidence Act, known as ROSCA, covers online offers that charge a customer after a trial or on a repeating basis. Law firm summaries describe three conditions. The seller must disclose the material terms before taking billing details, get the customer's express consent before charging, and give a simple way to stop the charges. The FTC has kept enforcing these rules in recent years.
The rules around cancellation have been in motion. A broader FTC cancellation rule from 2024 was struck down by a federal appeals court in July 2025, which left the older rules in place. The FTC then opened a new rulemaking in March 2026. States add their own requirements, and California's automatic renewal law is a well known example. Because the picture keeps changing, check the current rules for every state you sell in.
Processors read your offer page the way a regulator does
A bank reviewing a supplement subscription opens the sign up page and looks for a few specific things. Is the price after the trial shown near the button? Is the billing date clear? Does the customer actively agree to the terms? Is there an obvious way to cancel? Does the name on the card statement match the brand? A page that hides these answers tells the bank to expect disputes, and it may lead to a higher reserve or a decline. Our guide to subscription billing for high risk merchants covers the structure in more detail.
Six billing terms that lower disputes
- Show the full price and the first billing date next to the order button, in plain text.
- Ask for a clear tick box or similar confirmation of the trial terms.
- Send a reminder email a few days before the first charge.
- Let customers cancel online in one or two steps, and confirm by email.
- Use a billing descriptor that matches your brand and includes a support contact.
- Refund quickly when a customer complains, before a dispute is filed.
Each of these removes a reason for the customer to call the bank. Together they also give you evidence if a dispute does arrive. Our article on how to reduce chargebacks as a high risk merchant goes deeper on dispute alerts and response.
What this means for a supplement merchant account
Banks sort merchants by how predictable the disputes are. A supplement brand with a clear offer, reminders and easy cancellation looks predictable, and it can ask for better terms after a few clean months. A brand with hidden terms looks risky and pays for it through reserves and tighter limits. A dedicated merchant account, underwritten by a bank that has reviewed the offer, gives you written terms and a stable base for growth. You can see how we place supplement brands on our nutraceuticals merchant account page, and our nutraceutical payment processing guide covers the wider picture.
This article is general information and not legal advice. Subscription and cancellation rules vary by state and change over time, so confirm your obligations with a qualified adviser.
Selling Supplements on Subscription?
CERF places supplement and nutraceutical brands with acquiring banks that review the offer up front. Terms are agreed in writing before approval.
Talk to CERF About Your Options